Tokugawa Nariaki of Mito was a person who was reprimanded by the shogunate and ordered into retirement and confinement. On the 13th day of the 3rd month of Kaei 2 (1849), the shogunate lifted the order it had issued to Nariaki forbidding him from involvement in the domain’s administration. The occasion was, in the 7th month of Kōka 2 (1845), a request to borrow a telescope from Abe Masahiro. Sohō records this as the first window that the shut-in Nariaki opened to the outside.
After this, long letters urging the rebuilding of the domain and coastal defense arrived at Abe’s without ceasing. Sohō identifies Mito as the head house of the idea of expelling foreigners, and calls Aizawa Seishisai’s Shinron the book of its teaching. Kawaji Toshiakira, the Nara magistrate, who read this in Kaei 2, gave a harsh assessment. While calling it an argument that would place men in a position of death to fight, he wrote 7 days later that Aizawa was probably a considerable figure. Fujita Tōko, who was close to Nariaki, also wrote to a friend that he wished to quickly return to the Bunsei 8 order to drive away foreign ships.
Yet though there was thought, there was no preparation, and only a little coastal defense was built at Uraga and Bōsō. Nariaki submitted opinions on coastal defense many times from the Tenpō era onward, but Sohō writes that the shogunate did not adopt them. What the shogunate adopted instead was a policy of not letting people know of affairs abroad. Fujita Tōko lamented that this was like covering one’s ears after the thunder had already sounded. Sohō praised as an excellent argument the words of Katsu Kaishū explaining the harm of shutting off information.
Another thread toward revival was Nariaki’s child, the later Tokugawa Yoshinobu. In the 9th month of Kōka 4 (1847), he succeeded to the Hitotsubashi house. Shogun Tokugawa Ieyoshi repeatedly visited his residence, joining him in chanting and dance, and Sohō records that they were like father and son. On the 2nd day of the 5th month of Kaei 1, Yoshinobu visited his father at Komagome for the first time, and on the 11th day of the 12th month he astonished people with his skill in archery. In the same month, senior councilor Matsudaira Noriyasu conveyed word of an engagement with Chiyohime, daughter of Ichijō Tadaka.
Conditions were attached to the lifting of the order. These were that he refrain from acting on his own judgment, and that he not employ Toda Ginjirō and Fujita Toranosuke again. On the 15th day of the 3rd month, Nariaki sent a letter to Yoshiatsu, who had become domain lord at age 13, urging him to end discord within the domain. At the deer hunt at Koganehara on the 18th day of the 3rd month as well, he looked into old regulations and sent them to Abe. The closing of the poem he presented expressed a wish to drive out foreigners.
On the 21st day of the 9th month, Ieyoshi visited the Mito residence at Koishikawa, and himself worked a boat at Kōrakuen. At the evening banquet, Nariaki presented a folding screen of chrysanthemums that he had painted himself. Sohō writes that the gloom since Kōka 1 seemed to have lifted, yet the domain’s administration remained in the hands of those opposed to him. Yoshiatsu did not accept his father’s arguments, and even into Kaei 2 father and son had not become reconciled.
From the request to borrow a telescope to the boating party at Kōrakuen, these 4 years can be traced through Sohō’s Kinsei Nihon kokuminshi, The Situation before Perry’s Arrival.
The Seventh Month of Kōka 2: A Single Telescope
The seventh month of Kōka 2 (1845).Original
The matter at hand was a request to borrow the telescope that Abe owned.OriginalOriginal
In the fifth month of the previous year, Nariaki had been reprimanded by the shogunate and ordered into retirement and confinement.Original
He was forty-five at the time.Original
In the eleventh month of that year the confinement was lifted, but he was not permitted to take any part whatsoever in the domain’s administration.Original
Tokutomi Sohō writes that the borrowing of the telescope was the first small window that this shut-in man opened toward the outside world.OriginalOriginal
而して彼の雄心は固より已む能はず、弘化二年七月、彼は閣老阿部正弘所藏の望遠鏡借用を申込、機緣として、彼と信書を往復するに至つた
Open the original page at the National Diet LibraryFrom this occasion, an exchange of letters began between Nariaki and Abe.Original
About domain reform.Original
About national defense.Original
Tokutomi Sohō reports that long letters were sent to Abe “almost without a break.”OriginalOriginal
Mito’s Pure Expel-the-Barbarians Doctrine
The original home of the expel-the-barbarians doctrine is Mito.Original
So Tokutomi Sohō declares, calling Aizawa Seishisai’s Shinron its “gospel” and “scripture.”OriginalOriginal
In Kaei 2 (1849), Kawaji Toshiakira, magistrate of Nara, read this Shinron.Original
He was a capable official of the shogunate.Original
His assessment was harsh.Original
It was, he said, a doctrine that placed men in mortal peril to force a desperate fight, no doubt meant to follow the precedent of Hōjō Tokimune beheading the envoys of the Yuan; but in an age when daimyo must be employed, things could not go as they had in the past.Original
Even so, in his diary seven days later he wrote, “this must be quite a remarkable person,” and wanted to know who the author was.Original
He had been stirred, Tokutomi Sohō reads.OriginalOriginal
新論の意、先づ人を死地に置て、必死の場より、戰をなす積りに御座候。故に北條時宗が、元の使を斬たりし例による積りにて候。これ孫子より出たる論にて、おもしろきことには候得共、其時の大將は、誰にすべしと云、人選論は、素より前以出來申間敷義に有之。又當時大名を御遣ひなさるゝ世になりては、少もいにしへの風にはまいり不申候
Open the original page at the National Diet LibraryFujita Tōko, called Nariaki’s trusted blade, was likewise an uncompromising advocate of expelling the barbarians.Original
In a letter dated the seventeenth day of the fourth month of Kaei 1, sent from his retreat at Takekuma to Takahashi Taichirō, he wrote as follows.Original
The meaning was that he wished, even one day sooner, to return to the expulsion order of Bunsei 8 — this, he said, was his earnest wish.OriginalOriginal
There could have been no posturing in a letter to a close comrade, Tokutomi Sohō says.Original
Before Perry’s arrival, lord and retainers alike in Mito held to a pure doctrine of expelling the barbarians, and their argument came down entirely to the single word “war.”Original
And with this opinion, Nariaki continued to provoke the shogunate’s officials.OriginalOriginal
Expelling the Barbarians Empty-Handed, a Secretive Shogunate
But though there was doctrine, there was no preparation.Original
Tokutomi Sohō writes that only a little coastal defense had been built at Uraga and Bōsō.OriginalOriginal
In the third month of Kaei 1, Asano Nagayoshi, magistrate of Uraga, went to Uraga on the shogun’s direct order.Original
What he carried with him was Nariaki’s Meikun Ippanshō.Original
Andō Masayoshi, a junior inspector of the shogunate, had copied out a volume and added a preface as a parting gift.Original
Even Mito, the very home of the expel-the-barbarians doctrine, had no preparation.Original
If so, then the shogunate and the various domains alike merely chanted “expel the barbarians” while folding their arms, letting precious years pass in vain.OriginalOriginal
The responsibility for this did not lie with Mito, Tokutomi Sohō declares flatly.Original
From the Tenpō years onward Nariaki had repeatedly submitted proposals on coastal defense, but the shogunate adopted not a single one.OriginalOriginal
What the shogunate adopted instead was a policy of secrecy.Original
Tokutomi Sohō cites the example of Matsudaira Sadanobu suppressing Hayashi Shihei’s Sangoku Tsūran and Kaikoku Heidan.Original
Even while England was invading China nearby, the shogunate tried to keep even this from becoming generally known.Original
Fujita Tōko lamented in a letter dated the twenty-seventh day of the third month of Kaei 1.Original
“It is as though one stops one’s ears only after the sudden thunderclap; the times are deeply lamentable, lamentable indeed.”Original
That is to say, it was like covering one’s ears only after the thunder had already sounded — the times, he said, were lamentable.OriginalOriginal
Here Tokutomi Sohō quotes at length the words of Katsu Kaishū.Original
Katsu rages that, as a result of forbidding the study of Western books and the making of instruments, and of shutting the eyes and ears of the people, whenever a foreign ship merely asked for firewood and water its intentions were suspected as malicious, and whenever one took soundings it was resented as an insult to the dignity of the nation.Original
Not knowing the enemy, and not knowing oneself.
“Secrecy is the very source of this harm.”Original
Tokutomi Sohō called this “truly a perfect argument.”OriginalOriginal
Please consult the original page images for this source.
Open the original page at the National Diet LibraryThe Boy Who Came to Komagome
In the course of Nariaki’s revival, there was one more thread.Original
This was his son Shichirōmaro, later Hitotsubashi Yoshinobu.OriginalOriginal
In the ninth month of Kōka 4 (1847), Shichirōmaro succeeded to the Hitotsubashi house.Original
Tokutomi Sohō judges that there is no doubt this was a measure by which Shogun Tokugawa Ieyoshi was considerate of Nariaki’s feelings.Original
Ieyoshi said that Shichirōmaro closely resembled the late Yoshimasa, and his reputation in the Ōoku was good as well.OriginalOriginal
Please consult the original page images for this source.
Open the original page at the National Diet LibraryOn the sixteenth day of the third month of Kaei 1, Ieyoshi visited the Hitotsubashi residence.Original
He visited frequently thereafter; when the shogun sang, Yoshinobu danced, and when Yoshinobu sang, the shogun danced.Original
Tokutomi Sohō writes that it was “just as if they were father and son.”OriginalOriginal
On the second day of the fifth month of that year, Yoshinobu visited his father at the Komagome residence for the first time.Original
Nariaki came out to the second chamber to greet him.Original
In the inner hall there was singing and dancing, and Yoshinobu danced wearing a dance robe of Yamato brocade that had been given to him by the shogun.Original
On the eleventh day of the twelfth month, he shot five arrows at a target bundle together with his elder brother Gorōmaro, astonishing everyone.Original
It is said that Nariaki’s joy overflowed between his brows.OriginalOriginal
On the fourth day of the same month, the senior councilor Matsudaira Noriyasu, acting as shogunal envoy, informed Yoshinobu of his engagement to Chiyohime, daughter of Ichijō Tadaka.Original
This was arranged through the senior lady-in-waiting Anekōji of the Ōoku.Original
On the third day of the previous month, it had been privately conveyed to the attached chief retainer of Mito that Itonomiya, daughter of Arisugawa no Miya, would become the shogun’s adopted daughter and be married to the Mito domain lord Tokugawa Yoshiatsu.Original
Thus a single boy fulfilled the role of “peace envoy” linking his natural father and the shogun.OriginalOriginal
The thirteenth day of the third month of Kaei 2 (1849)
Thus that day came.Original
On the thirteenth day of the third month of Kaei 2 (1849), the shogunate released the three related lords—Matsudaira Yoritane, Matsudaira Yorinobu, and Matsudaira Yorinawa—from their guardianship, and the domain lord Yoshiatsu was to govern in person.Original
At the same time, the order forbidding Nariaki from interfering in domain government was also lifted.Original
Yoshiatsu became domain lord at the age of thirteen.Original
Its governance lay in the hands of the three related lords and the senior officials whom Nariaki called the wicked faction.Original
For nearly six years, a man of fierce fighting spirit had looked on from the sidelines.Original
Two days later, on the fifteenth day of the third month, Nariaki wrote a letter to Yoshiatsu.Original
He wrote that he was “like a general of a defeated army,” but since there was also a saying that one becomes a good physician only after breaking one’s arm three times, he would set aside his shame and offer his words.Original
He urged that discord within the domain be ended, and that all but those who violated the warrior’s way be treated with leniency.Original
However, the lifting of the ban came with restrictions.Original
In matters of reward, punishment, and personnel within the domain, Nariaki was to consult with the domain lord and chief retainers, and refrain from unilateral decisive action.Original
And the reappointment of Toda Ginjirō and Fujita Toranosuke was expressly forbidden—”there shall be no such thing”—their names singled out as a direct warning.Original
Tokutomi Sohō writes that this shows how heavily burdened with reputation, and how regarded as dangerous figures, the two men were.OriginalOriginal
其政は三連枝-松平讃岐守賴胤、松平大學頭賴誠、松平播磨守賴繩-の後見によりて、專ら齊昭を排斥したる所謂る藤田黨の天狗派に對する姦黨の手に歸し
Open the original page at the National Diet LibraryDust at Koganehara
On the same eighteenth day of the third month, the shogun Tokugawa Ieyoshi held a deer hunt at Koganehara.Original
This was a house custom dating from Ieyasu’s time, which Yoshimune had revived and which Ieyoshi now restored again.OriginalOriginal
狩獵は、家康以來の家法とも、家傳とも云ふ可く家光の如きも、屢ば之を試み、中興の主、吉宗に至りて、大いに之を恢復した。而して將軍家慶亦た嘉永二年二月に於て、之を擧行した
Open the original page at the National Diet LibraryNariaki was well versed in ancient precedent.Original
On the fourteenth day of the second month he sent a research report to Abe, repeatedly proposing that sake be given to the farmers around the hunting ground, and that the game be cooked and given to the attendants.OriginalOriginal
Abe Masahiro had gone ahead to Matsudo post station the previous night.Original
The shogun arrived at the hour of nine at night, rested briefly at Shōryūji at the hour of seven and a half, and proceeded to the hunting ground on foot and on horseback.Original
At the signal cannon, guns fired all at once, and dust rose so thick that one could not even tell boar from deer.Original
“It truly resembled a battlefield,” Abe wrote to Nariaki.Original
The shogun himself speared two hares and gave the battle surcoat he was wearing to Abe.Original
Abe took one boar and two hares with a bamboo spear.Original
Nariaki too was given game by the shogun.OriginalOriginal
Nariaki presented a eulogistic poem for this hunt.Original
Its closing line read, “May we rely on sacred authority to repel the four barbarians.”Original
It expresses the wish that, by sacred authority, the four barbarians be driven off.Original
Tokutomi Sohō writes that Nariaki’s intent was, in every respect, to drive off the four barbarians.Original
Perhaps, within the dust of the hunt, he was after all seeing a battlefield.Original
Autumn Leaves at Kōrakuen
On the twenty-first day of the ninth month of Kaei 2 (1849), Ieyoshi visited the Mito residence at Koishikawa.Original
The stated purpose was to pay a visit to Hōjuin, the wife of the late Narinobu.Original
Tokutomi Sohō surmises that it was in fact to meet Nariaki.OriginalOriginal
Nariaki had written to Abe on the eleventh day of the seventh month.Original
Since it would be his wife’s first audience, he wrote, “in part joyful, in part anxious, we count the days and await it.”Original
He meant that it was at once a joy and a worry, and that they were counting the days as they waited.OriginalOriginal
Ieyoshi left the castle early in the morning and arrived at around eight in the morning.Original
He granted an audience to Nariaki and others in the main chamber, and just past noon strolled through Kōrakuen.Original
The attendant ladies-in-waiting numbered over a hundred, and the garden’s autumn leaves shone against the vermilion-lacquered boat on the pond.Original
The shogun himself took up the pole and moved the boat.Original
At night, candles were lit at Kantokutei and a drinking banquet was held.Original
Nariaki presented a screen of chrysanthemums he had painted himself, and Ieyoshi gladly accepted it.Original
Tokutomi Sohō writes that the frustration pent up since Kōka 1 (1844) seemed to open all at once.OriginalOriginal
But within that same residence, domain governance still remained in the hands of the opposing faction.Original
The domain lord Yoshiatsu had grown up among those men since the age of thirteen, and tended not to approve of his father’s words and conduct.Original
The misfortunes of Mito were the result of his father’s self-will having offended the shogunate, and submissive obedience was what would bring good fortune to the domain and filial devotion to his father.Original
Nariaki stopped going to the Koishikawa residence, and it was in the winter of Kōka 4 (1847) that Tōko wrote his letter of remonstrance, but even by Kaei 2 (1849) father and son had not been reconciled.OriginalOriginal
而して豫て利かぬ氣の齊昭は、之を苦々敷事に思ひ、愈よ父子疎隔を來たし、小石川邸へも往來せず、その爲めに藤田東湖の六三-六七〕如きは、憂慮の餘、齊昭の反省を希うてゐる。〔參照藤田の諫書は、弘化四年の冬であつたが、嘉永二年に至りても、父子の關係、今以て融和せず
Open the original page at the National Diet LibraryWhat was it that Nariaki had regained over the course of four years?Original
Beginning with a telescope, and passing through a boy’s dance, game from a hunt, and a shogun rowing a boat, he was restored as a relative of Ieyoshi.Original
Yet the policy of expulsion remained unaccomplished, Toda and Fujita remained forbidden, and the lord of the residence where the screen had been presented kept his father at a distance.Original
It can also be read that what had returned was the man Nariaki himself, not Nariaki’s governance.
The shogun gripping the pole beneath the autumn leaves, and the retired lord gazing upon him.Original
Does not the brightness of that one day, rather, foreshadow the darkness that was to follow?Original
| Source text | Kinsei Nihon kokuminshi, The Situation before Perry’s Arrival (1929). National Diet Library Digital Collections (PDM). PID 3431221 |
| Checked against | Ishin shiryō kōyō, vol. 1 (1937). PID 1046665 |
| Dates and names | All 12 dates in the text exist in the calendar for their year, and the Western years given alongside them agree. Of the 16 people named in the text, 13 also appear in Ishin shiryō kōyō, vol. 1. |
| English gates | 120 of 120 sentences passed the checks on the English text. |
This article is a reading of Kinsei Nihon kokuminshi, The Situation before Perry’s Arrival. Tokutomi Sohō’s views are those of the 1920s and 1930s and may differ from current scholarship. The source text is a century old and may differ from current scholarship.
